The Ripple Effect: Workforce Development and Small Businesses

Podcast: Play in new window | Download (Duration: 7:04 — 8.1MB) | Embed

Audio Transcript

Introduction

Welcome to The Ripple Effect, where we explore how policies impact our economy beyond the surface level. Today, we’re diving into workforce development—a policy that often gets headlines but rarely receives the deep analysis it deserves. We’ll explore the first, second, and third-order effects of workforce development policies on small businesses. By looking beyond the initial impacts, we can better understand how these policies might shape the economic landscape, particularly for the small business community.

First-Order Effects: Immediate Impact

When a candidate proposes investments in workforce development, the first-order effects typically focus on direct benefits to the workforce, particularly for primary employers. A primary employer is a business that drives local economic activity by producing goods or services that bring in money from outside the region to support the local ecosystem.

So, how do politicians propose investing in workforce development? Well, investments in workforce development can occur in several ways:

Education and Training Programs: Funding for vocational training, apprenticeships, adult education, and other programs that help workers gain new skills or upgrade existing ones. For example, the government might fund training programs for wind turbine technicians to meet the growing demands of the renewable energy sector.
Partnerships with Employers: Collaborating with businesses, including both primary and secondary employers, to ensure that training programs align with industry needs. As a reference, a secondary employer is a business that supports primary employers and their employees by providing local goods or services, relying on the economic activity generated by primary employers to sustain the local economy. Partnerships could mean funding customized training programs that address specific skill gaps in industries like our wind power technology example.
Support Services: Providing resources such as career counseling, job placement services, and support for unemployed or underemployed individuals to help them transition into new roles when a primary employer closes up shop.
Infrastructure Development: Investing in educational institutions, community colleges, and workforce development centers that offer reskilling programs.

For small businesses, the immediate benefit is access to a more skilled labor pool, even if they aren’t the primary focus of these programs. For example, a local maintenance company that services wind turbines might benefit from hiring newly trained technicians who have gone through government-funded vocational programs.

However, there’s a flip side. The funding for these programs usually comes from taxpayer dollars. This means that everyone might experience a tax increase. Alternatively, the funding could result in deficit spending or reductions in funding for other programs. For small business owners and other taxpayers, these fiscal changes could present additional financial challenges, especially for those already operating on thin margins.

Second-Order Effects: Ripple Through the Economy

As we move to the second-order effects, the broader economic impacts begin to unfold. Workforce development leads to a more skilled labor force, which in turn increases productivity across industries. For primary employers, such as wind power companies, this means greater efficiency and the potential to scale their operations more rapidly. Small businesses that provide services or products to these larger companies can benefit indirectly.

For instance, a local supplier of wind turbine components may see an increase in demand as the wind power sector grows, driven by a more capable workforce. Similarly, secondary employers, such as local engineering firms that design parts for wind turbines, might see new business opportunities as the primary sector expands.

However, as workers gain new skills and become more valuable, they often demand higher wages. For small businesses, this leads to increased payroll costs, which can strain their financial resources. Additionally, if workforce development programs are not well-targeted, there is a risk of creating a mismatch in the labor market, where the skills developed don’t align with the actual needs of local small businesses. This could result in some small businesses struggling to find workers with the specific skills they require despite overall improvements in the workforce.

Third-Order Effects: Long-Term Consequences

Finally, let’s consider the third-order effects—the long-term consequences that often go unnoticed. Over time, a more skilled workforce can drive significant economic growth within a community. In the case of our wind power technology example, successful workforce development programs can establish a region as a hub for renewable energy, attracting more businesses and investments to the area.

For small businesses, this growth can be both an opportunity and a challenge. On one hand, a thriving wind power industry could lead to increased demand for local services, from catering to legal services. On the other hand, the success of the industry might attract larger companies to the area, increasing competition for both customers and skilled workers. Small businesses might find it challenging to retain their workforce as larger companies offer more competitive salaries and benefits.

Additionally, if the local economy becomes heavily dependent on a single industry, like wind power, small businesses could face risks if that industry experiences a downturn. Diversifying the local economy becomes crucial, but it can be difficult for small businesses to pivot if their operations have become closely tied to the success of a single sector.

Conclusion

In conclusion, understanding the distinction between primary and secondary employers is key to grasping the first, second, and third-order effects of workforce development policies. First-order effects often provide direct benefits to primary employers, while second-order effects create a ripple, indirectly boosting secondary employers and their local ecosystems. Third-order effects reveal long-term consequences, such as shifts in local economies, competition, and workforce retention. By considering all these layers, we can make more informed decisions on how policies shape the future of small businesses and the broader economy.

Thanks for tuning in to The Ripple Effect. Join us next time as we explore the far-reaching consequences of another key policy. Remember, understanding the first, second, and third-order effects can help us make better decisions at the ballot box—decisions that truly support our small business community.